Call 716-693-7477 | Get Directions

Order Online

Fatman’s Pizza Menus

Order Online

Satisfy Your Cravings

For comfort food enthusiasts in Buffalo, NY seeking a culinary adventure beyond the traditional, look no further than Fatman’s Pizza. We’re more than just a pizza restaurant – we’re a destination for food lovers who want to experience the best of Buffalo’s culinary scene. Our menu is filled with delicious, handcrafted dishes that are made from scratch using only the freshest ingredients. From our famous pizza to our mouthwatering wings, calzones, subs, and more, there’s something for everyone at Fatman’s Pizza!

 

Wings at Pizza Restaurant in Buffalo, NY | Fatman's Pizza
Pizza Restaurant in Buffalo, NY | Fatman's Pizza

Order for pickup or delivery!

Call 716-693-7477

Order Online

Our Menu

Our menu is a testament to Buffalo’s vibrant food scene, offering a unique blend of flavors and local ingredients that set us apart. From savory appetizers to hearty entrees and indulgent desserts, each item is crafted with passion and care to deliver an unforgettable dining experience. Explore our specials and discover what makes us a favorite among food lovers in Buffalo!

Everyday Combos & Specials

Monthly Specials

Pizza of the Month

Calzone of the Month

Monthly Specialty Pizza List

Pizza

Wings & Fingers

Calzones

Subs

Salads

Apps & Sides

Seafood

Dessert

Pizza

Our pizzas are crafted using our signature semi-sweet sauce or garlic marinara sauce. The default option is semi-sweet unless otherwise specified.
Enhance any pizza by adding a delectable garlic crust!

Toppings

Extra Cheese, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Banana Peppers, Green Peppers, Jalapenos, Black Olives, Green Olives, Bacon, Tomatoes, Ham, Spinach, Meatballs, Fresh Garlic, Pineapple and Cherry Peppers

Pizza Pricing

Personal: $8.99

Small: $14.99

Large: $20.99

1/2 Tray: $27.49

Tray: $38.99

Additional Toppings

Personal: $1.00
Small: $1.50
Large: $3.00
1/2 Tray: $4.00
Tray: $5.50

Pizza of the Month

Small $23.99 | Large $34.99 | 1/2 Tray $39.99 | Tray $49.99

January

Calamari Fra Diavolo

Deep fried calamari topped with mozzarella and provolone cheeses over a spicy calabrian marinara sauce.

February

Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Pepper
Our homemade buffalo chicken stuffed peppers, diced, topped with mozzarella cheese, over a garlic butter base

March

Five Cheese
yellow american, provolone, mozzarella, cheddar and swiss-american cheeses over a semi-sweet sauce.

April

Apple Cider Whiskey BBQ Pulled Pork
Slow cooked pulled pork, pickled jalapenos, red onion and pickle chips, topped with cheddar and mozzarella over our homemade apple cider whiskey bbq. Served with coleslaw on side.

May

Stuffed Green Pepper
Seasoned taco beef, diced green peppers, onions, seasoned diced tomatoes, taco rice, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese over an enchilada sauce base.

June

Fat Mac

Chopped burger, pickle, onion, yellow american, mozzarella cheese over 1,000 island base.

July

Hot Honey, Ricotta and Basil

Fresh basil, ricotta dollops over our garlic marinara sauce, finished with a hot honey drizzle.

August

Spicy Mediterranean Sausage

Hot sausage crumbles, sun dried tomatoes, red onion, calabrian peppers, black olives, fresh mozzarella, over a white garlic base.

September

Pittsburgh Steak

Chopped ribeye steak, fresh cut french fries, cheddar, mozzarella cheese over a riviera vinaigrette dressing base.

October

Chicken and Waffles

diced boneless wings, shaken in a hot honey maple sauce, chopped belgain waffles, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese over a buttered crust.

November

Sicilian Meatball
Chopped meatballs, roasted red peppers, fresh spinach, provolone, and mozzarella cheeses over our white garlic sauce.

December

Chicken Parm de Vodka

Diced chicken fingers topped with mozzarella cheese over a homemade vodka sauce base.

Mac-n-Cheese Pizza of The Month

Small $25.99 | Large $37.49 | 1/2 Tray $44.99 | Tray $54.99

January

Buffalo Chicken
Diced chicken fingers, shaken in hot sauce, tossed with our homemade mac-n-cheese over a bleu cheese base.

February

Pizza Supreme

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms in a cheddar and mozzarella mac-n-cheese, over our garlic marinara sauce.

March

Spinach and Artichoke
Fresh spinach, artichoke hearts, white cheddar, provolone, cream cheese in a homemade mac-n-cheese over garlic butter crust.

April

BBQ Chicken

Diced chicken fingers, shaken in bbq sauce, tossed with our homemade mac-n-cheese over a ranch dressing base.

May

Jalapeno Popper

Diced jalapenos, bacon crumbles, cheddar, cream cheese, mozzarella in a homemade mac-n-cheese over a garlic butter crust.

June

Philly Steak

Ribeye steak, sautéed green peppers, mushrooms and onions in a homemade mac-n-cheese over a white garlic base.

July

Ham, Potato, Bacon
Diced ham, bacon crumbles, tater tots in a homemade mac-n-cheese, over a garlic butter crust.

August

Stuffed Pepper Alfredo
Our award winning stuffed hungarian peppers in a homemade alfredo mac-n-cheese over a garlic butter crust.

September

Tex-Mex
Seasoned taco beef, homemade queso mac-n-cheese over enchilada sauce, topped with homemade pico de gallo

October

Cheddar Broccoli
Broccoli florets, cheddar, and mozzarella in a homemade mac-n-cheese, over a garlic butter crust.

November

Nashville Chicken Stuffed Pepper
Our homemade Nashville chicken stuffed peppers, dill pickle, in a homemade mac-n-cheese, topped with mozzarella over a garlic butter base, and a hot honey drizzle.

December

Loaded Spaghetti Parm

Tossed pasta noodles, diced meatballs, crumbled sausage, provolone, and mozzarella cheeses over our garlic marinara sauce.

Calzone of The Month

$14.99

January

Maple Bacon Rodeo Burger

Chopped burger, onion rings, cheddar, mozzarella, ricotta cheeses with our maple bacon bbq on side.

February

Pizza Flip
Filled with cheese and pepperoni, topped with our semi sweet sauce, and melted mozzarella.

March

Five Cheese

Our homemade mac-n-cheese, mozzarella, and ricotta cheese. Served with semi sweet on side.

April

Breakfast
Bacon crumbles, breakfast sausage, scrambled eggs, yellow-american, mozzarella and ricotta cheese. Served with maple syrup and topped with honey butter.

May

Tequila Lime Grilled Chicken

Grilled tequila lime chicken with sautéed habaneros, red onion, cheddar, mozzarella, and ricotta. Served with ( ) on side.

June

Meat Lovers
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, mozzarella, and ricotta cheeses. Served with semi-sweet sauce on side.

July

All-American

Grilled Sahlen’s hot dogs, baked beans, onions, relish, cheddar, and mozzarella. Served with ketchup and mustard on side.

August

Chicken Bacon Ranch

diced chicken fingers, bacon crumbles, cheddar, mozzarella, and ricotta cheeses, with ranch on side.

September

Spicy Fried Pickle

Deep fried pickle chips, cheddar, mozzarella, ricotta cheese. Served with spicy ranch dressing on side.

October

Hawaiian
Ham, pineapple, provolone, mozzarella, and ricotta cheese. Served with semi-sweet on side.

November

Stinger Supreme

Choice of chicken fingers, ribeye steak, bacon, mozzarella, provolone, and ricotta cheese. Served with our homemade bleu cheese on side.

December

French Onion

Caramelized onions, provolone, mozzarella, ricotta cheese. Served with ( ) on side.

Specialty Pizzas of The Month

White Tomato and Onion

Price:
Small $21.49
Large $31.99
1/2 Tray $36.49
Tray $44.99

Traditional tomato and onion or your choice of up to 4 veggies with our homemade white sauce.

Poor Man’s Lasagna Pizza

Price:
Small $21.49
Large $31.99
1/2 Tray $36.49
Tray $44.99

Chopped meatballs, fresh ricotta, and mozzarella, on our garlic marinara sauce.

Hawaiian Pizza

Price:
Small $21.49
Large $31.99
1/2 Tray $36.49
Tray $44.99

Chopped pineapple and ham, with our semi-sweet sauce, topped with mozzarella and provolone cheese.

Stuffed Hungarian Pepper Pizza

Price:
Small $23.99
Large $34.99
1/2 Tray $39.99
Tray $49.99

With homemade stuffed hungarian peppers and a garlic butter sauce.

Philly Chicken Pizza

Price:
Small $25.99
Large $37.49
1/2 Tray $44.99
Tray $54.99

With green peppers, mushrooms, and onions, plus a three-cheese blend on our homemade white sauce.

The Works Pizza

Price:
Small $25.99
Large $37.49
1/2 Tray $44.99
Tray $54.99

With pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, onions, banana peppers, black olives, and green olives.

White Veggie

Price:
Small $21.49
Large $31.99
1/2 Tray $36.49
Tray $44.99

Choice of up to four (4) toppings with our homemade white sauce.

Honey Sriracha Pizza

Price:
Small $21.49
Large $31.99
1/2 Tray $36.49
Tray $44.99

Choice of pepperoni or sausage on our garlic marinara sauce with a honey sriracha drizzle, and a fresh basil finish.

Chicken Finger Pizza

Price:
Small $23.99
Large $34.99
1/2 Tray $39.99
Tray $49.99

Choice of fingers, with bleu cheese sauce.

Meat Lovers Pizza

Price:
Small $23.99
Large $34.99
1/2 Tray $39.99
Tray $49.99

With pepperoni, italian sausage, bacon, and ham.

Philly Steak Pizza

Price:
Small $25.99
Large $37.49
1/2 Tray $44.99
Tray $54.99

With green peppers, mushrooms, and onions plus a three-cheese blend on our homemade white sauce.

Split Pizza

Price:
Large +$3.00
1/2 Tray +$3.50
Tray +$5.00

Get two different pizzas in one! The higher-priced pizza choice will determine the price. The Works Pizza is not available for split.

Chicken Finger Pizza

Price:
Small $23.99
Large $34.99
1/2 Tray $39.99
Tray $49.99

A five-cheese homemade mac-n-cheese on a garlic crust.

Whole Pizzas

Now offering our original semi-sweet sauce, or garlic marinara sauce. Semi-sweet will be served unless requested otherwise.

Add a garlic crust to any pizza!

Toppings: Extra Cheese, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Banana Peppers, Green Peppers, Jalapenos, Black Olives, Green Olives, Bacon, Tomatoes, Ham, Spinach, Meatballs, Fresh Garlic, Pineapple and Cherry Peppers

Pizza by The Slice
  • Pizza by The Slice
  • Whole Pizzas
$3.49

Cheese Pizza Slice

  • Cheese and cheese pepperoni available daily (while supplies last)
$3.79

Slice of The Day

See our menu for the Chef's choice!
$9.69

Two Pizza Slices & Drink Special

  • Available while supplies last.
We do not sell "make your own slices" to order

Wings & Fingers

Served with blue cheese, carrots, and celery. Wings cannot be returned for being too hot! Try our wings and fingers on the chargrill!
$1.50 upcharge ($3.00 for a bucket of wings)
Extra Bleu Cheese $1.50
Extra Veggies $1.50

Sauce Options

Plain, Hot, Medium, Mild, and BBQ

Specialty Options

($1.00 upcharge)
Cajun, Garlic Parm, Buffalo Garlic, Cajun BBQ, Horseradish Mustard, Mum's Sauce, Inferno*, Honey BBQ, Honey Hot, Honey Garlic, Honey Sriracha, Maple Bacon BBQ, Jamaican Jerk, Cajun Honey Butter BBQ, Honey Mustard, Lemon Pepper, Spicy Lemon Pepper, Apple Cider Whiskey BBQ, Italian Herbs, Old Bay, Spicy Peach, Spicy Pickle, Tennessee Smoke, Tequila Lime (*wings cannot be returned for being too hot)

Boneless Wings

Served with homemade bleu cheese, carrots, and celery.
Single (12) $14.99
Double (24) $25.99
Triple (36) $38.99
Bucket (60) $57.99

Chicken Wings

Served with homemade bleu cheese, carrots and celery
10 $13.99
20 $27.99
30 $38.99
50 $61.99

Chicken Fingers

Served with fresh-cut french fries, homemade bleu cheese, carrots, and celery
Single (6) $15.99
Double (12) $29.99

Calzones

Served with sides of pizza sauce unless specified otherwise.

Cheese Calzone

$9.99
With ricotta and mozzarella.

Cheese & One Topping Calzone

$11.99
See the pizza section for toppings.

Chicken Finger Calzone

$13.99
Choice of sauce, served with bleu cheese.

Stuffed Hungarian Pepper Calzone

$13.99
With our homemade stuffed peppers.

Subs

Cold Subs & Hot Subs

All rolls are toasted. Subs come with a choice of lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Subs come with a choice of mayonnaise or oil. Subs come with a choice of Swiss-American cheese, provolone, or yellow-American cheese. (Unless specified otherwise)

All Items
  • All Items
  • Cold Subs
  • Hot Subs
  • Specialty Subs

Royal

8" $10.99 12" $14.99
Your choice of Italian sausage, ribeye steak, or grilled chicken with grilled hot capicola.

Pizza Sub

8" $9.49 12" $11.99
Your favorite pizza in sub-form! Includes one topping, with your choice of sauce.

Philly

8" $11.99 12" $15.49
Your choice of ribeye steak, grilled chicken breast, or Italian sausage with sauteed green peppers, mushrooms, and onions; topped with melted yellow American cheese.

Chicken Parm

8" $10.49 12" $13.99
Chicken fingers topped with your choice of sauce and topped with melted mozzarella.

Chicken Finger

8" $11.99 12" $15.99
Made with your choice of fingers, sauces listed under "Wings, Fingers and Boneless Wings."

Meatball Parm

8" $10.49 12" $13.99
Loaded with 1-oz meatballs topped with your choice of sauce, and melted mozzarella.

Stinger

8" $12.49 12" $17.99
A Buffalo staple! Made with ribeye steak, chicken fingers sauced your way, and melted provolone cheese.

Stuffed Pepper Parm

8" $10.99 12" $14.99
Our homemade sausage-stuffed Hungarian peppers topped with your choice of sauce and melted mozzarella.

Sausage Parm

8" $10.49 12" $13.99
Grilled Italian sausage topped with your choice of sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese. Ask to load it up!

Bologna and Onion

8" $9.49 12" $11.99
Diced fried bologna with sauteed onions and melted yellow American cheese.

Steak and Cheese

8" $10.49 12" $13.99
Made with chopped ribeye steak.

Grilled Chicken Sub

8" $10.49 12" $14.99
Made with fresh 6-oz diced double-lobe chicken breast

Salads

Dressings will be served on the side, served with garlic toast.

Dressings:

Bleu Cheese, Golden Italian, Ranch,
Sweet Italian, Greek, Caesar, Lite Italian, French, Oil and Vinegar

Add Ons:

Add Chicken: $3.00/$6.00
Extra Meat: $3.00
Extra Dressing: $1.00

Caesar Salad

A bed of romaine lettuce topped with croutons and shredded parmesan cheese.
Small $8.49 Large $11.99

Chef Salad

A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, and mozzarella cheese.
Small $8.49 Large $11.99

Greek Salad

A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, black and green olives, feta cheese, and pepperoncini; served with pita.
Small $9.99 Large $12.99

Julienne Salad

A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, ham, turkey, and mozzarella cheese.
Small $10.99 Large $14.99

Antipasto Salad

A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, ham, capicola, salami, pepperoni and mozzarella cheese.
Small $10.99 Large $14.99

Buffalo Chicken Salad

A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, and mozzarella cheese with your choice of fingers.
Small $10.99 Large $14.99

Apps & Sides

Fried Mushrooms

$7.99
Served with bleu cheese

Nashville Chicken Stuffed Peppers

$13.99
Topped with dill pickle chips

Fresh Cut French Fries

$4.49
Cut fresh in-house, then deep-fried to perfection!

Deli Style Potato Chips

$4.49
Your choice of original or cajun style.

Onion Rings

$7.99
Thick-cut beer-battered onion rings.

Mozzarella Sticks

$7.99
Deep-fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside.

Pizza Logs

$8.99
Your favorite pizza in log form!

Taco Logs

$8.99
Served with sour cream.

Homemade Mac & Cheese

$9.99
Made to order!

Bread Sticks

$9.99
Served with our semi-sweet sauce.

Stuffed Hungarian Peppers

$13.99
An order of three with a homemade sausage stuffing recipe. Baked and topped with mozzarella cheese.

Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Peppers

$13.99
An order of three filled with a homemade buffalo chicken mix. Baked and topped with mozzarella cheese.

Potato Skins

$9.99
Four homemade potato skins topped with melted cheddar cheese and bacon crumbles. Served with a side of sour cream.

Jalapeño Poppers

$7.99
Five homemade jalapeño poppers stuffed with cream cheese, cheddar, and bacon. Served with a side of sour cream.

Sweet Potato Fries

$7.99
Fresh-cut sweet potato fries tossed with honey and butter.

Extra Bleu Cheese

$1.50
2 oz cup of our homemade bleu cheese

Ranch

$1.00
2 oz cup of ranch

Everyday Combos & Specials

Any 8″ Sub, Side & Drink Special

$4.75
Add a side and drink to your 8" sub with your choice of Pepsi products. Side options: chips, fries, or salad. Mac and cheese or onion rings for $2.50 upcharge.

Small Pizza (1) Topping, 10 Wings

$29.99

Small Pizza (1) Topping, Single Finger or (12) Boneless Wings

$30.99

Large Pizza (1) Topping, 20 Wings

$49.99

Large Pizza (1) Topping, Double Fingers or (24) Boneless Wings

$50.99

Half Tray (1) Topping, 30 Wings

$69.99

Full Tray (1) Topping, 50 Wings

$99.99

Seafood Friday

Only Available on Friday

Beer Battered Fish Fry

An 8-10 oz homemade beer-battered cod fish fry. Served with fresh-cut french fries, homemade coleslaw, tartar sauce, a lemon wedge, and garlic toast.

$16.99

Shrimp Basket

10 jumbo deep-fried tail-on shrimp served with our fresh-cut french fries, homemade coleslaw, cocktail sauce, a lemon wedge, and garlic toast.

$14.99

Dessert

Apple Pie Logs

Served with caramel sauce.

$8.99

Cinnamon Sticks

Topped with vanilla icing.

$6.99

Monthly Specials

MAY 2026 SPECIALS

Fried Green Tomato Grilled Cheese Club $14.99
Crispy fried green tomatoes, thick cut bacon between melted provolone, cheddar and yellow american cheese on grilled texas toast. Served with deli style potato chips and a side of poblano avocado ranch.

Alabama Fried Chicken Sandwich $14.99
Breaded chicken cutlet topped with dill pickle chips, Duke’s Alabama white sauce, and provolone cheese on a round roll. Served with fresh cut fries and a pickle.

Codfather Wrap $15.99
Deep fried fish bites, crispy fresh cut fries, coleslaw, tartar sauce and yellow american cheese in a grilled white wrap. Served with fresh cut fries and a pickle.

The “Red” $15.99
Chopped ribeye steak, buffalo chicken stuffed pepper, and melted mozzarella sticks between two pieces of garlic texas toast. Served with fresh cut fries and a pickle.

White Pizza Sub
Honey BBQ Ham & Turkey Warp with Fries
Double Smash Pizza Burger Melt with Fries
Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Pepper Loaded Fries

Feeling hungry yet? Call 716-693-7477 or order online today!