Fatman’s Pizza Menus
Satisfy Your Cravings
For comfort food enthusiasts in Buffalo, NY seeking a culinary adventure beyond the traditional, look no further than Fatman’s Pizza. We’re more than just a pizza restaurant – we’re a destination for food lovers who want to experience the best of Buffalo’s culinary scene. Our menu is filled with delicious, handcrafted dishes that are made from scratch using only the freshest ingredients. From our famous pizza to our mouthwatering wings, calzones, subs, and more, there’s something for everyone at Fatman’s Pizza!
Order for pickup or delivery!
Call 716-693-7477
Order Online
Our menu is a testament to Buffalo’s vibrant food scene, offering a unique blend of flavors and local ingredients that set us apart. From savory appetizers to hearty entrees and indulgent desserts, each item is crafted with passion and care to deliver an unforgettable dining experience. Explore our specials and discover what makes us a favorite among food lovers in Buffalo!
Everyday Combos & Specials
Monthly Specials
Pizza of the Month
Calzone of the Month
Monthly Specialty Pizza List
Pizza
Wings & Fingers
Calzones
Subs
Salads
Apps & Sides
Seafood
Dessert
Our pizzas are crafted using our signature semi-sweet sauce or garlic marinara sauce. The default option is semi-sweet unless otherwise specified.
Enhance any pizza by adding a delectable garlic crust!
Toppings
Extra Cheese, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Banana Peppers, Green Peppers, Jalapenos, Black Olives, Green Olives, Bacon, Tomatoes, Ham, Spinach, Meatballs, Fresh Garlic, Pineapple and Cherry Peppers
Pizza Pricing
Personal: $8.99
Small: $14.99
Large: $20.99
1/2 Tray: $27.49
Tray: $38.99
Additional Toppings
Personal: $1.00
Small: $1.50
Large: $3.00
1/2 Tray: $4.00
Tray: $5.50
Pizza of the Month
Small $23.99 | Large $34.99 | 1/2 Tray $39.99 | Tray $49.99
January
Calamari Fra Diavolo
February
March
April
May
June
Fat Mac
July
Hot Honey, Ricotta and Basil
August
Spicy Mediterranean Sausage
September
Pittsburgh Steak
October
Chicken and Waffles
November
December
Chicken Parm de Vodka
Mac-n-Cheese Pizza of The Month
Small $25.99 | Large $37.49 | 1/2 Tray $44.99 | Tray $54.99
January
February
Pizza Supreme
March
April
May
Jalapeno Popper
June
Philly Steak
July
August
September
October
November
December
Loaded Spaghetti Parm
Calzones Pizza of The Month
January
February
March
Five Cheese
April
May
Tequila Lime Grilled Chicken
June
July
All-American
August
Chicken Bacon Ranch
September
Spicy Fried Pickle
October
November
Stinger Supreme
December
French Onion
Whole Pizzas
Now offering our original semi-sweet sauce, or garlic marinara sauce. Semi-sweet will be served unless requested otherwise.
Add a garlic crust to any pizza!
Toppings: Extra Cheese, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Banana Peppers, Green Peppers, Jalapenos, Black Olives, Green Olives, Bacon, Tomatoes, Ham, Spinach, Meatballs, Fresh Garlic, Pineapple and Cherry Peppers
Served with blue cheese, carrots, and celery. Wings cannot be returned for being too hot! Try our wings and fingers on the chargrill!
$1.50 upcharge ($3.00 for a bucket of wings)
Extra Bleu Cheese $1.50
Extra Veggies $1.50
Calzones
Served with sides of pizza sauce unless specified otherwise.
Calzone of The Month
calzone of the month price: $14.99
January
Sausage in the Grass
February
Chicken Bacon Ranch
March
Cheddar Broccoli
April
Swiss Mushroom Burger
May
Five Cheese
June
Honey Sriracha
July
Hawaiian
August
Pizza Flip
September
Breakfast
October
Mac-n-Cheese
November
Veggie
December
3-Alarm Steak
Subs
Cold Subs & Hot Subs
All rolls are toasted. Subs come with a choice of lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Subs come with a choice of mayonnaise or oil. Subs come with a choice of Swiss-American cheese, provolone, or yellow-American cheese. (Unless specified otherwise)
Salads
Dressings will be served on the side, served with garlic toast.
Dressings:
Bleu Cheese, Golden Italian, Ranch,
Sweet Italian, Greek, Caesar, Lite Italian, French, Oil and Vinegar
Add Ons:
Add Chicken: $3.00/$6.00
Extra Meat: $3.00
Extra Dressing: $1.00
Apps & Sides
Everyday Combos & Specials
Seafood Friday
Only Available on Friday
Beer Battered Fish Fry
An 8-10 oz homemade beer-battered cod fish fry. Served with fresh-cut french fries, homemade coleslaw, tartar sauce, a lemon wedge, and garlic toast.
$16.99
Shrimp Basket
10 jumbo deep-fried tail-on shrimp served with our fresh-cut french fries, homemade coleslaw, cocktail sauce, a lemon wedge, and garlic toast.
$14.99
Dessert
Apple Pie Logs
Served with caramel sauce.
$8.99
Cinnamon Sticks
Topped with vanilla icing.
$6.99
Monthly Specials
February 2026 Specials
Loaded “Fring” 11.99
Abed of french fries and crispy onion rings topped with bacon crumbles, cheddar, and mozzarella cheeses; baked to perfection. Served with a homemade chipotle ranch on the side.
Calabrian Stromboli 13.99
A homemade stromboli filled with pepperoni, capicola, salami, calabrian peppers, provolone, and mozzarella cheese. Served with our garlic marinara on the side.
“Fat Mac and Mac” Wrap 14.99
Chopped smashed burgers, fresh cut french fries, mac-n-cheese bites, lettuce, tomato, pickles and 1,000 island dressing in a grilled white tortilla. Served with fresh cut french fries and a pickle.
Bloody Mary Crispy Chicken Sandwich
15.99
Everything bagel seasoned fried chicken thigh, topped with crispy bacon, dill pickle chips, banana peppers, pepperjack cheese and a spicy bloody mary horseradish aioli on a toasted round roll. Served with fresh cut french fries and a pickle.
Feeling hungry yet? Call 716-693-7477 or order online today!